The Christian Researcher
  • Home
  • My Book
  • Podcast
  • Store
  • Articles
  • Contact
  • Book Reviews
  • Book Recommendations
  • Preacher's Study Videos
  • Matthew Study Material
  • Gospel Meetings Video/Audio
  • Quotes For Contemplation
  • Free Downloads
    • Jehovah's Witnesses, Mormons, and Seventh Day Adventists Renounced
  • Bible Correspondence Course
  • Online Tools
  • Audio Books, Debates, and Sermons
    • The Battey - Kniffen Discussion on Marriage, Divorce, and Remarriage
    • The Holy Spirit by George Battey
    • Premillennialism
    • Sermon on the Mt. by George Battey
    • Teacher Training Material
    • Open Bible Studies Audio/Video
  • Links
  • The Hutto - Cutter Debate

The Herald of Truth's Error - By Nathan Battey

10/14/2015

0 Comments

 
Picture
The Herald of Truth's Error.pdf
File Size: 105 kb
File Type: pdf
Download File

Herald of Truth Fund Raising Pamphlet.pdf
File Size: 2413 kb
File Type: pdf
Download File

Autonomy vs Dependency Chart.pdf
File Size: 62 kb
File Type: pdf
Download File

What is the Herald of Truth?
 
Herald of Truth is a missionary society that operates both a nationwide and international television and radio program.  In addition to its media efforts, in recent years Herald of Truth has begun to sponsor numerous missionaries in foreign fields and conducts its own foreign works.  In short, Herald of Truth is an organization operating separate from the church to do the work God gave the church.  Herald of Truth is funded by numerous digressive churches of Christ as well as donations from society as a whole.
 
How it began:
 
Herald of Truth began as a radio program and evangelistic effort of the Highland Avenue Church of Christ in Abilene, TX in 1952. Herald of Truth began airing on 31 American Broadcasting Co. stations and, within its first year, it is estimated over 5,000 people were converted.
 
Because of the tremendous success of the radio program, Highland Church decided to begin a television program to pair with its radio program.   In 1953 a fund raising campaign was begun with the hope of raising enough money to broadcast Herald of Truth on 62 television stations across the nation. The goal of the campaign was to get 1,000 churches to commit to sending $27 per week so a potential viewing audience of 10 million viewers could be reached.  
 
The television program was successfully launched in 1954 on 50 stations and by the 1970’s had expanded to 468 radio stations and 152 television programs.  The program met with much success, but was not without controversy.
 
By the mid 1950’s and throughout the 1960’s, the Herald of Truth program was the source of heated debate.  Defenders of the program included such noted men as Guy N. Woods, Thomas B. Warren, and Batsell Barrett Baxter while other noted brethren such as Roy E. Cogdill and W. Curtis Porter opposed it. Papers and publishing companies also got involved in the controversy with Gospel Advocate defending the program and Gospel Guardian and Truth Magazine opposing it.  Numerous formal and written debates resulted including the Cogdill – Woods debate, and the Arlington Meeting.  The Herald of Truth controversy ultimately escalated to the point of major division between what came to be known as the Main Line Churches of Christ and the Non-Institutionals.
 
Why the controversy?
 
Why would brethren and faithful preachers oppose a program that was converting thousands? What could possibly be wrong with Churches of Christ being put on the map and a good program gaining national attention and competing with the denominations?  How could such a blessing be the source of so much division and controversy?
 
Points of controversy:
 
In discussing the points of controversy, one of Herald of Truth’s defenders will be allowed to present his own case for consideration.  The following quotes come from Jack Meyer Sr. and are recorded in his book, The Preacher and His Work and were delivered as a strong defense for Herald of Truth.
 
Argument #1:
“Now those who oppose Herald of Truth and any such form of congregational cooperation, have, quite sincerely in most cases, “gone to seed” in using this “no example” argument.  Every such argument which they make is made by the anti-class… group.” (p. 166).
 
“This is where you are going to have to make up your mind as to where you stand, and I appeal to you to think long time before being stampeded into extremism by a radical doctrine that crusades under the name of keeping the church sound, but is actually headed into the same results as those of the anti-Sunday school and Ketcherside-Garrett groups.” (p. 171)
 
Meyer’s Argument:  Those who oppose the Herald of Truth are making the same arguments as the anti-Sunday school proponents (and must therefore be wrong).
 
Meyer correctly observed what many who were opposed to the Herald of Truth failed to realize:  The arguments used by Roy Cogdill and others were essentially the same arguments used against Sunday school classes.  In classic digressive fashion, Meyer felt he had answered the issue by merely labeling those opposed to Sunday schools and the Herald of Truth as “Antis”.  Unfortunately for Brother Meyer, the linking of the two topics did not and does not prove the Scripturalness of either Sunday school classes or Herald of Truth. 
 
What Brother Meyer failed to realize is that Bible silence forbids rather than permits (Colossians 3:17).  If Scripture does not authorize a practice, it is to be rejected.  Quoting passages that authorize teaching (such as Matthew 28:19-20) does not make void the rules for how the teaching is to take place (1 Corinthians 14) or how the church is supposed to accomplish its task (1 Corinthians 3:10; 2 Timothy 1:13-14).
 
Argument #2:
“But before you are deceived by that line of reasoning, be sure that you are not driven to extremism by extreme pressing of a true principle.  And mark this: when brethren do this, they wind up by taking positions or urging principles that are not true.  Press a true principle to an untrue extreme, and you will the manufacture untrue principles.” (p. 166)
 
Meyer’s Argument:  “Press a true principle to an untrue extreme, and you will the manufacture untrue principles.”
 
Meyer’s second argument appears to be an attack on logic.  Truth cannot be pressed into error.  Truth can be abandoned in favor of error, but truth cannot be taken to untrue extremes.  Asking for a Bible examples or patterns that support Sunday school classes or the Herald of Truth program is no more extreme than requiring such a pattern for baptism or communion (Colossians 3:17).  Labeling a thing as “extreme” does not prove it to be unscriptural.
 
Argument #3:
“For example, they argue that when Homewood church, Birmingham, with which I labor, sends money to Highland church in Abilene, TX., to help support our national gospel broadcast, The Herald of Truth, our congregational autonomy (independence) is violated.  On the contrary, we exercise that congregational independence by deciding to send that money, by earmarking it to be sent for a specific purpose.  The Highland church exercises its independence by deciding to invite churches to assist, by accepting the money, and carrying on the program with money sent for that purpose.  The autonomy of no church is violated.  Highland church contracts for the program and can terminate the program when thought best.  But we understand that when we send our money and send it with that knowledge.  Just where has any contributing church, including Highland, lost its autonomy?  Only in the charges of those who continue to make these false charges and make good brethren believe such to be true.” (p. 167)
 
Meyer’s Argument:  Autonomy is not violated since the money has been freely given and is earmarked for a certain work and then used for that work.
 
First, Meyer contradicts himself by speaking of the Herald of Truth program as an independent work of Highland Church and at the same time stating, “to help support our national gospel broadcast,” (p. 167).  To whom does the program belong?  Does it belong to Highland Church or to all sponsoring churches?
 
Second, Meyer correctly notes autonomy has to do with independence, yet is wrong in claiming Highland Church was maintaining its independence while conducting the Herald of Truth program.  Meyer himself notes this fact later when he states, “assisting Highland with a program which those brethren found themselves able to carry on in part, but for which they need help maintaining in its entirety.” (p. 169).  Highland Church, though full of good intentions, bit off more than it could chew when attempting to air a television program on 62 channels and reach an audience of 10 million people.  When a church starts asking 1,000 churches to donate $27 per week to their program, they are creating a dependent work.  Whether Highland church was dependent on 1,000 churches, or 100 churches, or 1 church makes little difference other than magnifying the dependence.  Dependence is dependence regardless of severity. The fact that Highland Church had to settle for beginning 50 television programs rather than 62 emphasizes they were dependent and unable to act independently of a brotherhood. 
 
In extreme situations a congregation may be forced to become dependent on other congregations (such as the Judean churches in 2 Corinthians 8), but such a situation is a far cry from creating dependency through a national television program.   There is a difference between a congregation suffering unavoidable dependence (2 Corinthians 8) and a congregation creating debt and expecting the brotherhood to tote the note for them.  When congregations decide to take on a work, they must “count the cost, whether they have enough to finish it.” (Luke 14:28). 
 
Lastly, halfway through his argument on autonomy, Meyer switched from discussing Highland Church’s independence to discussing her ability to self-govern.  Both independence and self-government are a part of autonomy, yet independence and self-government are not the same thing.  Here is why the distinction between independence and self-government must be maintained: A congregation cannot scripturally choose to become dependent upon another congregation and at the same time claim autonomy.  When a church chooses to undertake a work greater than her ability and then requests assistance of accomplishing said work, she is not acting autonomously.
 
Argument #4:
“Then they charge that Highland church is turned into a missionary society, and that contributing churches are sending their money to such an organization.  Wrong.  The difference is this: a missionary society is a board of men, members of various congregations, over the country, banded into an organization outside of and separate and apart from a congregation to do the work of the church, in competition with the church.  But Highland church is not such an organization, but is a congregation under the oversight of its elders, according to New Testament authorization. (Acts 20:17,28; 14:23)  So, in supporting this great program of blanketing our nation, and many adjacent nations, with the gospel, you are not sending money to a missionary society, but to a congregation.”      (p. 167)
 
Meyer’s Argument:  Herald of Truth does not operate as a Missionary Society.
 
First, even if it could be argued that Herald of Truth was not a Missionary Society in the 50’s and 60’s, it is freely admitted it is such today.  Thus, those who opposed Herald of Truth on the grounds of where it would lead have been justified by time.
 
Second, it is impossible for a single congregation to scripturally and independently maintain a work that spans 468 radio stations and 152 television programs.  Such an endeavor requires organization in the areas where it is being broadcast that is beyond the scope of a single congregation.  To argue such is possible is to argue a single church can successfully (and scripturally) conduct mission efforts in 468+ cities each week all on its own. 
 
When a substructure greater or smaller than the local congregation begins to be established and aids in or accomplishes the work of the congregation, a missionary society is being formed.  Such was the case with the Herald of Truth program and brethren who recognized such digression were to be commended.
 
Third, though Meyer correctly defined a missionary society, he misrepresented the issue by stating, “But Highland Church is not such an organization, but is a congregation under the oversight of its elders, according to New Testament authorization.”  No one was arguing Highland Church was a missionary society, but rather they had formed a missionary society of which they were head; there is a difference between the two statements.
 
When a single congregation receives money to do a work greater than their ability to independently maintain, and is forced to organize or coordinate with several other congregations in order to get “their” work accomplished, a missionary society has been formed to compete with the work of the local congregation.  God designed each church to complete its work independently, rather than as part of a super-structure.  When a church attempts to do a work larger than its ability, autonomy will be forfeited and a missionary society (however great or small) will be established.
 
As time unfolded, the Highland Church grew tired of operating a program as large as what Herald of Truth had become.  As a result they established Herald of Truth as an independent organization under its own oversight and in charge of its own funding.  The end result was merely a solidification of what had long been established.  Make no mistake; a missionary society had existed for a long time before Highland Church openly admitted its existence.
 
Argument #5:
“Then some of them charge that Herald of Truth is separate from the church, because for it Highland church, in Abilene, TX., has a separate bank account, a separate treasurer, and with one elder delegated to supervise it.  They seem to forget that congregations often employ this practice for special projects.  For example, when Homewood congregation launched a project looking ultimately to the building of our second and “main” building, we created a separate building fund account, and with one brother in charge of that fund.  That money was kept separate from our general fund, and the general fund treasurer never touched a dime of it.  That wasn’t because we lacked confidence in our general fund treasurer.  On the contrary, his job was a big one, and this treasureship for the building fund was to be a big one.  Further, to keep the two separate not only spread work among treasurers, instead of overloading one, but it simplified bookkeeping.  Too, we kept before the people that every penny which went into the building fund would go for that purpose, and could be spent for nothing else.  That helped to establish confidence and increased incentive.  Only after the building was finished and duly financed did we abolish the separate fund and vacate the office of a separate building fund treasurer.  While we had that plan, did that mean that our building fund was separate from the Homewood church?  That our treasurer for that fund was separate?  Did that mean that such fund constituted a separate organization?  That is all that the separate Herald of Truth fund in Highland church operation means… The foregoing Homewood practice has been standard with congregations, and it is not questioned in any quarter.” (p. 167-168)
 
Meyer’s 1st Argument:  Highland church has a separate account for the Herald of Truth program, but this is no different than having a separate building project fund.
 
Meyer argued that when congregations sent money to Highland Church for the Herald of Truth program, the money belonged to Highland Church and not Herald of Truth. The natural question would then be:  Could Highland Church use the money sent to her for any purpose she deemed worthy?  Or, must money sent for airing the Herald of Truth program only be spent on the program?  If the program were to end, must Highland give their money back to sponsoring congregations, or are they free to roll it over into another fund?
 
Earlier, Meyer acknowledged his home congregation of Homewood sent money “earmarked” for the Herald of Truth program to Highland Church.  Question:  If the money belongs to Highland church, what business does Homewood have in telling them how to spend it?
 
When one congregation sent money to another congregation in the New Testament, it was for the sake of a temporary need with the concept of completion in mind rather than an unending burden (2 Corinthians 8:10-15).  The Herald of Truth fund could not and cannot be classified as a temporary need; it was and is both ongoing and a want rather than a “need”.
 
The problem with Meyer’s argument is that a church’s independent building fund does not parallel with the dependent Herald of Truth fund.  Had Meyer paralleled a dependent building fund with Herald of Truth’s dependent fund, he would have been onto something (however unscriptural both sides of the parallel might have been). 
 
Meyer’s 2nd Argument:  How the money is separated for Herald of Truth is how we have always done things and must therefore be right.
 
One of the greatest tragedies of the church is its willingness to base current practices on tradition rather than Scripture.  Arguing how something has always been done is no answer for a “Thus saith the Lord” (Isaiah 45; Colossians 3:17).
 
Argument #6:
“We are carrying on our own program, and assisting Highland with a program which those brethren found themselves able to carry on in part, but for which they need help maintaining in its entirety.” (p.169)
 
Meyer’s Argument:  We are completing our own work and assisting Highland church with hers, though she makes her own decisions.
 
Question: Why must Meyer clarify his congregation is completing its own work only to admit that Highland Church is not completing hers?  Why clarify one congregation is operating independently if such does not matter?
 
Furthermore, Meyer’s statement begs the question of how much of their own work Highland Church was carrying.  If it takes 1,000 churches to make a weekly commitment to begin a work, it is questionable how much of the load the “owning” church is carrying.
 
 
The Bottom Line:
 
The Herald of Truth was and is an abandonment of the Biblical pattern and the creation of a monumental state of dependency.  The end did not and does not justify the means.  Division occurred because brethren recognized a departure from the biblical pattern, though they refused to see it in other areas (Sunday school) where the same arguments were applicable. 
 
May the Lord’s people learn from and remember the error of the Highland Church and the Herald of Truth program.  May congregations recognize their obligation to do all they can for the cause of Christ, yet not over-extend themselves beyond what they are able (2 Corinthians 8:12) or what is written            (1 Corinthians 4:6).
The Herald of Truth's Error.pdf
File Size: 105 kb
File Type: pdf
Download File

Herald of Truth Fundraising Pamphlet.pdf
File Size: 2413 kb
File Type: pdf
Download File

Autonomy vs Dependency Chart.pdf
File Size: 62 kb
File Type: pdf
Download File

Picture
Order a copy of Jack Meyer's book The Preacher and His Work
Picture
Order a copy of Roy Cogdill's excellent work against Institutionalism and the Herald of Truth program.
0 Comments

Your comment will be posted after it is approved.


Leave a Reply.

    Categories

    All
    1000 Year Reign
    1 Corinthians 11
    1 Timothy 2:8 15
    1 Timothy 2:8-15
    2016 Reading
    2 Corinthians
    7 Days Of Creation
    Abortion
    Acts 2
    A.D. 70 Theory
    Adam
    Adultery
    Age Of Accountability
    Alcohol
    Alexander Campbell
    Alleged Discrepancies
    Ananias And Sapphira
    Angels
    Animal Sacrifice
    Annihilation
    "Antis"
    Apologetics
    Apostasy
    Armageddon
    Astros
    Attitudes
    Audio Sermon
    Authority
    Autonomy
    Baalism
    Babel
    Bald Prophet
    Baptism
    Baptism Of Jesus
    Baptsim
    Bearing Arms
    Bears
    Beggars
    Best Books
    Bible And History
    Bible Atrocities
    Bible Authority
    Bible Classes
    Bible Commentaries
    Bible Difficulties
    Bible Interpretation
    Bible Knowledge
    Bible Pattern
    Bible Study Aids
    Bible Talk
    Biblical Theology
    Big Picture
    Billy Orten
    Bitterness
    Blasphemy Of The Holy Spirit
    Blood
    Boldness
    Book Of Acts
    Book Of Numbers
    Book Reviews
    Bookstore
    Book Suggestions
    Bruce Roebuck
    Calvary
    Calvinism
    Cannibalism
    Carnal Warfare
    Centurion
    Change
    Charity
    Cheating
    Christ
    Christian Colleges
    Christianity
    Christian Rock Music
    Christian Virtues
    Christ On Trial
    Church Co-operation
    Church Discipline
    Church Growth
    Church Leadership
    Church Of Christ
    Church Organization
    Collection
    Communion
    Confession
    Conflict Resolution
    Conquest
    Conscientious Objector
    Contemporary Christian Music
    Contribution
    Controversy
    Cost Of Business
    Covenant
    Coversion
    Creation
    Critical Issues
    David And Goliath
    Day Of Pentecost
    Deadpool
    Death
    Deathbed Conversion
    Death Of Child
    Death Of Christ
    Debate
    Decisive Cleansing
    Delusion
    Denominations
    Depression
    Destruction Of Jerusalem
    Difficult Passages
    Digression
    Division
    Divorce
    Doctrine
    Drinking
    Drunkenness
    Edification
    Elders
    Election
    Ephesians 2:8-9
    Eternal Life
    Eternal Rest
    Eternal Reward And Punishment
    Evangelism
    Evolution
    Examples Of Conversion
    Exodus
    Expository Preaching
    Ezekiel 18
    Facebook
    Faith
    Faith Alone
    Faithfulness
    False Doctrine
    False Worship
    Family
    Family Problems
    Family Worship
    Favorites
    Fellowship
    Foreknowledge
    Forgiveness
    Forgiveness In The Old Testament
    Foundational Topics
    Free Book
    Free WIll
    Gambling
    G. C. Brewer
    Genealogy
    Genocide
    Gentiles
    George Battey
    Giving
    Glen Osburn
    Gluttony
    Gnosticism
    God
    God-Centered
    God's Special People
    Gospel Meeting Sermons
    Gospel Of Luke
    Government
    Grace
    Great Reads
    Grief
    Hair
    Heaven
    Hebrew Parallelism
    Hebrews
    Hell
    Herald Of Truth
    Heresy
    Heretics
    Hermeneutics
    Heroes
    Hiram Christopher
    Historisity Of The Gospels
    History Of The Church
    Holiness
    Holistic Heathenism
    Holy Spirit
    Holy Spirit Baptism
    Holy Wars
    Homosexuality
    Hope
    How Great Is Our God!
    Humility
    Immorality
    Independence
    Infallibility
    Infant Baptism
    Inherited Sin
    Innovations
    Inspiration Of The Bible
    Institutionalism
    Instrumental Music
    Interpretation
    Intertestamental History
    Introduction
    Introduction To Matthew
    Irving Church Of Christ
    Isaiah
    Islam
    Israel
    Israel In The Wilderness
    James 2
    James Cating
    Jeremiah
    Jerry Dickinson
    Jesus
    Jewish Trials
    Jews
    Jihad
    Joe Hisle
    John The Baptist
    Joseph And Mary
    J. Ridley Stroop
    Judgment
    J. W. McGarvey
    Kevin Presley
    Kingdom Of God
    Language
    Last Days
    Law
    Law Keeping
    Law Making
    Laying On Of Hands
    Lazarus
    Legalism
    Lessons Of Youth
    Lies
    Light To The Gentiles
    Literature
    Living Hell
    Logic
    Lord's Supper
    Love
    Luke-Acts
    Lying
    Marcion
    Mark 16:16
    Mark Twain
    Marriage
    Martin Luther
    Matthew
    Matthew Study
    Maturity
    Mercy
    Messianic Prophecy
    Metonymy
    Microphones
    Military Service
    Miracles
    Missionary Societies
    Mission Of John The Baptist
    Mission Work
    M. Lynwood Smith
    Moral Issues
    Morris Reynolds
    Moses
    Movies
    Multiple Cups
    Murder
    Nadab And Abihu
    Nathan Battey
    Natural Law
    Nature Of God
    Necessary Inference
    New David
    New Exodus
    New Law
    New Moses
    New Testament
    New Testament Church
    New Testament In The Old
    No-Exception Doctrine
    Obedience
    Objections
    Old Testament
    Old Testament Lessons
    Old Testament Studies
    Omnipotence
    Omniscience
    One Cup
    Opa
    Order Of Worship
    Pacifism
    Papa
    Parables
    Parallelism
    Parents
    Partiality
    Paul
    Persecution
    Personal Offense
    Pharisees
    Placentophagy
    Poetry
    Police Service
    Politics
    Pornography
    Positive Law
    Prayer
    Preaching Publicly And Privately
    Premillennialism
    Premillennialsim
    Priest
    Priorities
    Prophecies
    Prophets
    Psalm 139
    Psalms
    Questions Of Interest
    Quran
    Racism
    Raising The Dead
    Randy Loftin
    Re-Baptism
    Recoding Equipment
    Re-Marriage
    Reprints
    Restoration Of Israel
    Revelation
    Romans 9
    Ron Courter
    Ronny Wade
    Sacred Name
    Sacrifice
    Sadducees
    Salvation
    Savage Death
    Scandal
    Scribes
    Seld Defense
    Self Defense
    Sermon Notes
    Sermon On The Mt.
    Sermon Preperation
    Sermons
    Service
    Sin
    Sinai
    Singing
    Slogans
    Social Gospel
    Sodom
    Songs
    Son Of David
    Son Of God
    Son Of Man
    Spiritual Immaturity
    Stephen
    Structure
    Studies In Matthew
    Study In Hebrews
    Suffering
    Tabernacle
    Teachings Of Christ
    Temptation
    Ten Commandments
    Terry Baze
    The Christian Age
    The Church
    The Church
    The Covering
    The Cross
    The Fullness Of Time
    The Last Day
    The Lord's Supper
    The Old Law
    The Resurrection
    The Shema
    Three Days And Three Nights
    Timothy McGrew
    Total Hereditary Depravity
    Training
    Transfiguration
    Trial Of Stephen
    Trilogy
    T-U-L-I-P
    Two Swords
    Type & Anti Type
    Type & Anti-Type
    Typology
    Understanding The Bible
    Unity
    Universal Church
    Unpardonable Sin
    Vain Worship
    Victory
    Video Studies
    Voting
    War
    Wayne Jackson
    Wine
    Wisdom
    Wise Counsel
    Witnesses
    W. L. Oliphant
    Women
    Women's Roles
    Worhip
    Worksheet
    Worship
    Young People

    Nathan Battey

    is an evangelist of the Church of Christ in Arlington, Texas. 

    RSS Feed

    Archives

    March 2021
    September 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    November 2019
    September 2019
    April 2019
    January 2019
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    April 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013



Picture
"The man who never reads will never be read; he who never quotes will never be quoted. He who will not use the thoughts of other men's brains proves that he has no brains of his own."  
                                                            - C. H. Spurgeon