The Christian Researcher
  • Home
  • My Book
  • Podcast
  • Store
  • Articles
  • Contact
  • Book Reviews
  • Book Recommendations
  • Preacher's Study Videos
  • Matthew Study Material
  • Gospel Meetings Video/Audio
  • Quotes For Contemplation
  • Free Downloads
    • Jehovah's Witnesses, Mormons, and Seventh Day Adventists Renounced
  • Bible Correspondence Course
  • Online Tools
  • Audio Books, Debates, and Sermons
    • The Battey - Kniffen Discussion on Marriage, Divorce, and Remarriage
    • The Holy Spirit by George Battey
    • Premillennialism
    • Sermon on the Mt. by George Battey
    • Teacher Training Material
    • Open Bible Studies Audio/Video
  • Links
  • The Hutto - Cutter Debate

Muscle and a Shovel: Answering the Critics by Nathan Battey

8/15/2014

 
Picture

Since publishing my review of Michael Shank’s book “Muscle and a Shovel”, I have received several emails and reviews from people who disagree with my recommendation.  I would thus like to briefly present some of the objections I consider legitimate questions, and attempt to answer them for the benefit of all.
The number one objection has been Mr. Randall’s assertion that the Baptist church believes John the Baptist founded it.  Critics claim Randall’s claim to be a false one that has been completely fabricated to dissuade people from becoming members of the Baptist church.

In answering this objection allow me to first point out that Randall’s statement in the book was a general statement; it is not claimed that every Baptist church claims to be founded by John the Baptists but rather that such is generally this is the case.  Second, the story being recalled takes place in the mid 1980’s and it is possible that Baptist doctrine has generally changed since then.  However, it remains a fact that through time Baptists have indeed claimed John the Baptists as the builder and founder of their Church.  In order to prove this one need only read the Porter-Bogard debate in which Mr. Ben Bogard (one of the most famous and outspoken Baptists preachers of his day) advocates freely that John the Baptist did indeed start the Baptist church.  Beyond this one debate there are numerous other debates and works that could be cited to establish this fact, but this one shall do for now. Complaints from critics, no matter how passionately made, are the cries of either ignorant or misinformed constituents. 

The second attack on the book is based on the concept that if a single error can be found in it, then the whole book must be disregarded as a result.  The problem with this reasoning is that the book is not claiming to be the inspired, inerrant word of God.  Rather, it claims to be an account of a man’s conversion and the arguments that caused him to rethink his salvation. 

One of the errors people point to in the book is Randall’s interpretation of the word “works” in Ephesians 2:8-9.  Randall takes the position that there are two types of works: works of the Old Law and works of faith.  While it is true that there are two types of works the “works” being spoken of in Ephesians 2:8-9 are not a contrast between works of the Old Law and works of faith; Ephesians 2:8-9 is contrasting works of merit and works of faithful obedience.  Though Randall is a little off on this point, his mistake does not discredit the entirety of his teaching.

The same type of critique arises later in the book when Randal discusses the “gift of the Holy Spirit” and takes the position that the gift referred to in Acts 2:38 is salvation.  Among churches of Christ there are three basic positions in regard to the gift of Acts 2:38:  the gift either refers to the Spirit himself, the gift of salvation, or the gift of miraculous abilities to the early church.  Though I disagree with Randall’s position of “the gift” referring to salvation(I believe it refers to miraculous abilities – for an article explaining the three positions click here), I do not feel his entire teaching should be rejected on this ground.  Though many disagree with my position on the Holy Spirit I pray that people will not discredit everything I teach because of their opposing position on this one topic.

Lastly, there are some who are concerned about Michael Shank’s occasional use of a curse word in recounting some of the actual conversations and events of his conversion.  Were I the author I would now have included such words (Mr. Shank does black out the majority of the word though the reader is able to understand what was said), but since I am not the author I suppose that decision is not up to me.  Mr. Shank in no way attempts to justify such language but rather presents it as part of his factual account of the conversations and events that took place.   In one since I can appreciate Shank’s raw, honest approach in disclosing the type of person he used to be and attempting to recount the events just as they were, while at the same time, were I in his position, I might not have been quite so forthright. 

All in all, I stand by my initial review of the book and still highly recommend it to others. 

In closing, I would like to share a personal success story that came about in part as a result of this book.  For the past three years Brother Joe Norton and I have studied on and off with a young man from a Baptist background.  About a month ago I gave of copy of Muscle and a Shovel to him and asked him to read it while I was out of the country.  The young man wrote me a few days later telling me he had finished the book and was trying to get some of his family members to read it as well.  When I returned home we spoke on the phone for an hour and a half and he decided he needed to be baptized.  After we baptized him the next day he admitted to me that Muscle and a Shovel had kind of pushed him over the edge in the right direction.  I say all of that to say this:  Muscle and a Shovel cannot replace the Word of God or having Bible studies with people, but I believe it can be used as a great tool in sharing the gospel, starting conversations, or giving people the push they need to do the right thing.

Click here to read my initial review of this book
Click Here to order a copy of the book

Comments are closed.

    Categories

    All
    1000 Year Reign
    1 Corinthians 11
    1 Timothy 2:8 15
    1 Timothy 2:8-15
    2016 Reading
    2 Corinthians
    7 Days Of Creation
    Abortion
    Acts 2
    A.D. 70 Theory
    Adam
    Adultery
    Age Of Accountability
    Alcohol
    Alexander Campbell
    Alleged Discrepancies
    Ananias And Sapphira
    Angels
    Animal Sacrifice
    Annihilation
    "Antis"
    Apologetics
    Apostasy
    Armageddon
    Astros
    Attitudes
    Audio Sermon
    Authority
    Autonomy
    Baalism
    Babel
    Bald Prophet
    Baptism
    Baptism Of Jesus
    Baptsim
    Bearing Arms
    Bears
    Beggars
    Best Books
    Bible And History
    Bible Atrocities
    Bible Authority
    Bible Classes
    Bible Commentaries
    Bible Difficulties
    Bible Interpretation
    Bible Knowledge
    Bible Pattern
    Bible Study Aids
    Bible Talk
    Biblical Theology
    Big Picture
    Billy Orten
    Bitterness
    Blasphemy Of The Holy Spirit
    Blood
    Boldness
    Book Of Acts
    Book Of Numbers
    Book Reviews
    Bookstore
    Book Suggestions
    Bruce Roebuck
    Calvary
    Calvinism
    Cannibalism
    Carnal Warfare
    Centurion
    Change
    Charity
    Cheating
    Christ
    Christian Colleges
    Christianity
    Christian Rock Music
    Christian Virtues
    Christ On Trial
    Church Co-operation
    Church Discipline
    Church Growth
    Church Leadership
    Church Of Christ
    Church Organization
    Collection
    Communion
    Confession
    Conflict Resolution
    Conquest
    Conscientious Objector
    Contemporary Christian Music
    Contribution
    Controversy
    Cost Of Business
    Covenant
    Coversion
    Creation
    Critical Issues
    David And Goliath
    Day Of Pentecost
    Deadpool
    Death
    Deathbed Conversion
    Death Of Child
    Death Of Christ
    Debate
    Decisive Cleansing
    Delusion
    Denominations
    Depression
    Destruction Of Jerusalem
    Difficult Passages
    Digression
    Division
    Divorce
    Doctrine
    Drinking
    Drunkenness
    Edification
    Elders
    Election
    Ephesians 2:8-9
    Eternal Life
    Eternal Rest
    Eternal Reward And Punishment
    Evangelism
    Evolution
    Examples Of Conversion
    Exodus
    Expository Preaching
    Ezekiel 18
    Facebook
    Faith
    Faith Alone
    Faithfulness
    False Doctrine
    False Worship
    Family
    Family Problems
    Family Worship
    Favorites
    Fellowship
    Foreknowledge
    Forgiveness
    Forgiveness In The Old Testament
    Foundational Topics
    Free Book
    Free WIll
    Gambling
    G. C. Brewer
    Genealogy
    Genocide
    Gentiles
    George Battey
    Giving
    Glen Osburn
    Gluttony
    Gnosticism
    God
    God-Centered
    God's Special People
    Gospel Meeting Sermons
    Gospel Of Luke
    Government
    Grace
    Great Reads
    Grief
    Hair
    Heaven
    Hebrew Parallelism
    Hebrews
    Hell
    Herald Of Truth
    Heresy
    Heretics
    Hermeneutics
    Heroes
    Hiram Christopher
    Historisity Of The Gospels
    History Of The Church
    Holiness
    Holistic Heathenism
    Holy Spirit
    Holy Spirit Baptism
    Holy Wars
    Homosexuality
    Hope
    How Great Is Our God!
    Humility
    Immorality
    Independence
    Infallibility
    Infant Baptism
    Inherited Sin
    Innovations
    Inspiration Of The Bible
    Institutionalism
    Instrumental Music
    Interpretation
    Intertestamental History
    Introduction
    Introduction To Matthew
    Irving Church Of Christ
    Isaiah
    Islam
    Israel
    Israel In The Wilderness
    James 2
    James Cating
    Jeremiah
    Jerry Dickinson
    Jesus
    Jewish Trials
    Jews
    Jihad
    Joe Hisle
    John The Baptist
    Joseph And Mary
    J. Ridley Stroop
    Judgment
    J. W. McGarvey
    Kevin Presley
    Kingdom Of God
    Language
    Last Days
    Law
    Law Keeping
    Law Making
    Laying On Of Hands
    Lazarus
    Legalism
    Lessons Of Youth
    Lies
    Light To The Gentiles
    Literature
    Living Hell
    Logic
    Lord's Supper
    Love
    Luke-Acts
    Lying
    Marcion
    Mark 16:16
    Mark Twain
    Marriage
    Martin Luther
    Matthew
    Matthew Study
    Maturity
    Mercy
    Messianic Prophecy
    Metonymy
    Microphones
    Military Service
    Miracles
    Missionary Societies
    Mission Of John The Baptist
    Mission Work
    M. Lynwood Smith
    Moral Issues
    Morris Reynolds
    Moses
    Movies
    Multiple Cups
    Murder
    Nadab And Abihu
    Nathan Battey
    Natural Law
    Nature Of God
    Necessary Inference
    New David
    New Exodus
    New Law
    New Moses
    New Testament
    New Testament Church
    New Testament In The Old
    No-Exception Doctrine
    Obedience
    Objections
    Old Testament
    Old Testament Lessons
    Old Testament Studies
    Omnipotence
    Omniscience
    One Cup
    Opa
    Order Of Worship
    Pacifism
    Papa
    Parables
    Parallelism
    Parents
    Partiality
    Paul
    Persecution
    Personal Offense
    Pharisees
    Placentophagy
    Poetry
    Police Service
    Politics
    Pornography
    Positive Law
    Prayer
    Preaching Publicly And Privately
    Premillennialism
    Premillennialsim
    Priest
    Priorities
    Prophecies
    Prophets
    Psalm 139
    Psalms
    Questions Of Interest
    Quran
    Racism
    Raising The Dead
    Randy Loftin
    Re-Baptism
    Recoding Equipment
    Re-Marriage
    Reprints
    Restoration Of Israel
    Revelation
    Romans 9
    Ron Courter
    Ronny Wade
    Sacred Name
    Sacrifice
    Sadducees
    Salvation
    Savage Death
    Scandal
    Scribes
    Seld Defense
    Self Defense
    Sermon Notes
    Sermon On The Mt.
    Sermon Preperation
    Sermons
    Service
    Sin
    Sinai
    Singing
    Slogans
    Social Gospel
    Sodom
    Songs
    Son Of David
    Son Of God
    Son Of Man
    Spiritual Immaturity
    Stephen
    Structure
    Studies In Matthew
    Study In Hebrews
    Suffering
    Tabernacle
    Teachings Of Christ
    Temptation
    Ten Commandments
    Terry Baze
    The Christian Age
    The Church
    The Church
    The Covering
    The Cross
    The Fullness Of Time
    The Last Day
    The Lord's Supper
    The Old Law
    The Resurrection
    The Shema
    Three Days And Three Nights
    Timothy McGrew
    Total Hereditary Depravity
    Training
    Transfiguration
    Trial Of Stephen
    Trilogy
    T-U-L-I-P
    Two Swords
    Type & Anti Type
    Type & Anti-Type
    Typology
    Understanding The Bible
    Unity
    Universal Church
    Unpardonable Sin
    Vain Worship
    Victory
    Video Studies
    Voting
    War
    Wayne Jackson
    Wine
    Wisdom
    Wise Counsel
    Witnesses
    W. L. Oliphant
    Women
    Women's Roles
    Worhip
    Worksheet
    Worship
    Young People

    Nathan Battey

    is an evangelist of the Church of Christ in Arlington, Texas. 

    RSS Feed

    Archives

    March 2021
    September 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    November 2019
    September 2019
    April 2019
    January 2019
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    April 2017
    February 2017
    January 2017
    December 2016
    November 2016
    October 2016
    September 2016
    August 2016
    July 2016
    June 2016
    May 2016
    April 2016
    March 2016
    February 2016
    January 2016
    December 2015
    November 2015
    October 2015
    September 2015
    August 2015
    July 2015
    June 2015
    May 2015
    April 2015
    February 2015
    January 2015
    November 2014
    October 2014
    September 2014
    August 2014
    July 2014
    June 2014
    May 2014
    April 2014
    March 2014
    January 2014
    December 2013
    November 2013
    October 2013
    September 2013
    August 2013
    July 2013
    June 2013
    May 2013
    April 2013
    March 2013
    February 2013



Picture
"The man who never reads will never be read; he who never quotes will never be quoted. He who will not use the thoughts of other men's brains proves that he has no brains of his own."  
                                                            - C. H. Spurgeon